Perelman , Informal Logic and the Historicity of Reason University of Windsor
نویسندگان
چکیده
Résumé: Dans un article posthume Perelman discute de sa décision de joindre sa théorie d’argumentation à la rhétorique plutôt qu’à la logique non formelle. Ceci est dû partiellement à l’importance qu’il accorde à l’auditoire, et partiellement à l’attitude négative des logiciens non formels à l’égard de la rhétorique. Dans cet article j’explore ses deux raisons en examinant les bénéfices que son œuvre peut apporter à la logique non formelle, et les contributions que celleci pourrait apporter au projet de Perelman et d’Olbrecht-Tyteca. © Informal Logic Vol. 26, No. 3 (2006): pp. 341-357.
منابع مشابه
Making Sense of “ Informal Logic ” 1 University of Windsor
This paper is an exercise in intellectual history, an attempt to understand how a specific term—”informal logic”— came to be interpreted in so many different ways. I trace the emergence and development of “informal logic” to help explain the many different meanings, how they emerged and how they are related. This paper is also, to some degree, an account of a movement that developed outside the...
متن کاملInformal Logic ’ s Influence on Philosophy Instruction University of Windsor
Résumé: La logique non formelle a débuté dans les années 1970 comme une critique des suppositions théoriques acceptées à cette époque dans les départements de philosophie aux États Unis et au Canada. Il y a eu un développement significatif dans la logique non formelle et dans l’enseignement de la pensée critique durant les dernières 35 années. Cet article est une étude pilote de l’influence de ...
متن کاملAn overview of formal models of argumentation and their application in philosophy
Argumentation is the process of supporting claims with grounds and defending them against attack. In the last decades argumentation has become an important topic in philosophy and artificial intelligence. In philosophy, the criticisms of Toulmin and Perelman of formal logic in the 1950s and 1960s gave rise to the field of informal logic, which studies informal models of reasoning and argumentat...
متن کاملRole of FDG-PET/CT in Assessing the Correlation Between Blood Pressure and Myocardial Metabolic Uptake
Objective(s): We aimed to assess the association between blood pressure and LV myocardial uptake of FDG, hypothesizing that subjects with raised blood pressure would have higher FDG uptake. Methods: We analyzed 86 healthy controls who underwent PET/CT imaging 180 minutes following FDG (4 MBq/Kg) administration. LV myocardial analysis was perf...
متن کاملA Pilot Study of FDG-PET/CT in Polycythemia Vera Using Global Analysis Techniques
Objective(s): Functional imaging presents a non-invasive process that may capture the hyper-metabolic nature of red bone marrow in myeloproliferative neoplasms, such as polycythemia vera (PV). Methods: This study analyzed the FDG-PET/CT scans (n=12) of six patients diagnosed with PV and six age-sex matched controls using a quantitative global analysis methodol...
متن کامل